Metro Rail to Dulles gets a new life – Airport Authority agrees to aboveground station

The Metropolitan Washington Airports Authority on Wednesday agreed to an aboveground Metro Station for Washington Dulles Airport, infusing fresh lease of life to the second phase of Dulles Metro Rail Project.

Dulles Main Terminal - Courtesy: Metropolitan Washington Airports Authority

Dulles Main Terminal - Courtesy: Metropolitan Washington Airports Authority

The Authority’s original decision to locate the station underground was opposed by all other stakeholders of the project, including the local county and state officials. The opposition was so blunt that Loudoun County even threatened to walk away from the project. Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood intervened and urged all the parties to come to a compromise, indicating that he would prefer an aboveground station to reduce the costs.
Even though everyone would prefer the more convenient underground location, the cost for that would be exorbitant. The contentious battle over the location of the station between the Airports Authority and local governments could have jeopardized the entire second phase of  the project, leaving Dulles Airport the only major airport in the Washington Baltimore area without a rail connection.
The Authority made the right call by agreeing to the aboveground station. This puts the project back on track.

Washington Dulles to have underground Metro Rail Station

Washington Dulles International Airport (IAD) has been my home airport for the past 15 years. So, when the airport authority made its decision on the location of the Metro Rail station, it prompted me to write down my thoughts on it.

Dulles Main Terminal - Courtesy: Metropolitan Washington Airports Authority

Dulles Main Terminal - Courtesy: Metropolitan Washington Airports Authority

Dulles used to be one of the most derided major airports in the United States. Located 23 miles West of downtown Washington, it was considered as a white elephant when opened in 1962. Most flights to the nation’s capital operated out of the close-in National Airport (since then renamed as Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport). With a signature Main Terminal, designed by the famous Finnish American Architect Eero Saarinen (who also designed the famous Gateway Arch in St. Louis and the futuristic TWA terminal in New York’s JFK airport), Dulles has one more unique feature: the mobile lounges. These odd looking vehicles transport passengers between terminals and planes.

Dulles has come a long way. A Perimeter Rule was put in place by the US Congress prohibiting long distance flights from National. The Washington DC area expanded rapidly and Northern Virginia became a hotbed for technology companies and government contractors. Dulles has become the busiest airport in the region, outpacing National and Baltimore Washington International. It is one of the major international gateways in the country today with United Airlines operating a major hub.

The major renovation programs in Dulles have helped it improve the standing among passengers. The recently launched AeroTrain connects the main terminal with all Concourses except Concourse D. I thoroughly enjoyed it on my recent trip to India. Even though the mobile lounges are still used to transport arriving international passengers, the train covers majority of the departing passengers. The redesigned Concourse B is also an excellent facility where most international airlines operate. But Concourses C and D are a different story. It is a shame that United has to operate its hub out of these outdated facilities. The airport authority and United have indefinitely shelved the plan to replace these facilities. Hopefully, a day will come to sunset these old structures.

The final piece of the puzzle is the metro rail access to the airport. Construction of Phase 1 is in progress. Phase 2 will bring the rail to the airport. The contentious question is the location of the airport station. With soaring costs, the original plan to build the station right under the main terminal was rejected. Two alternative proposals were put forth: an underground station closer to the main terminal and an above ground station farther away from the main terminal. The airport authority was right in selecting the underground station. This is more convenient to passengers with much shorter distance to cover than the above ground station. I know it is going to cost more. But, the long term vision of more user friendly station should be given preference over the short term, cheaper alternative that is not user friendly. I remember that when the Metro opened the station in Reagan National Airport, I avoided using it to the airport because my flights departed from Terminal A, which is a long walk (or take a shuttle bus). When Terminal B/C opened and connected directly to the metro station using the covered walkway, it was more convenient. A longer walk to the Terminal from the station could deter the passenger from using the rail, especially in Dulles with lots of international passengers.